Garcinia Cambogia for Weight Loss – Probably Not!

garciniaThere is always news in the media about the next weight loss magic bullet.  One of the latest is actually a fruit called  Garcinia Cambogia.  Some of the talk shows have been touting this as an easy way to lose weight without having to change your lifestyle at all.  I did some investigating and came upon this excerpt from the Natural Standard database.

Hydroxycitrate:  Controversial Weight-Loss Ingredient

Hydroxycitrate is a generic name for any salt of (-)-hydroxycitric acid (HCA), which occurs naturally in fruits from the genus Garcinia. HCA is found in particularly high concentrations in Garcinia cambogia, commonly called brindleberry or Malabar tamarind.

Hydroxycitrate is the active ingredient in a number of over-the-counter weight-loss products. Among the many dietary supplements that are advertised to aid in weight management, hydroxycitrate is distinguished by the large body of research examining its effectiveness, safety and mechanism of action. However, hydroxycitrate is also distinguishable by the conflicting and inconsistent nature of the studies, and by the controversy generated by these studies.

HCA is a competitive inhibitor of the enzyme ATP citrate lyase, which has a major role in synthesizing fatty acids in the body. HCA is also believed to reduce malonyl-CoA concentrations, leading to increased fatty acid oxidation. Therefore, it is believed that HCA promotes weight loss by interfering with fatty acid synthesis, promoting fat oxidation and reducing appetite.

A recent systematic review and meta-analysis showed a small but statistically significant weight-loss effect of HCA compared to placebo. However, gastrointestinal adverse effects were also twice as common in subjects taking HCA than in those taking placebo.

Several animal and human studies have supported the effectiveness of HCA for weight loss. Of these, the vast majority were funded or conducted by pharmaceutical companies, with one or more authors affiliated with a major supplier of HCA-based products.

Other studies have shown no effects of HCA on weight loss parameters (such as body weight reduction, blood/serum profiles, or satiety). One study, conducted at Columbia University and published in 1998 in the leading medical publication Journal of the American Medical Association, is considered to be strong evidence against the effectiveness of hydroxycitrate or HCA for weight loss.

However, proponents of HCA say that the high-fiber, low-calorie diet that was used in this study may have prevented the anti-obesity effects of hydroxycitrate.

Animal studies have shown that HCA may have toxic effects, such as testicular shrinkage and toxicity. However, the HCA used some of these studies reportedly contained large amounts of HCA lactone. In the free acid or lactone forms, HCA can potentially cause have negative effects on testicular development by chelating zinc, which can lead to zinc deficiency. Many commercial HCA products contain fully reacted calcium or potassium salts of HCA, so should have little or no free HCA acid or HCA lactone. Hydroxycitrate has been determined to be safe in several studies, and has been determined to be GRAS by an independent team of experts for use as a flavoring agent. Acidic conditions may promote lactone formation, even of fully reacted acid salts. Therefore, it should be cautioned that free HCA acid or HCA lactone may accumulate over time in acidic environments.

Taken together, the research thus far does not provide conclusive evidence that hydroxycitrate effectively promotes weight loss, either through metabolic processes or by inducing satiety. More research is needed to determine the safety and effectiveness of HCA-containing products.

So, what can we conclude from all that information?  Will Garcinia Cambogia help you lose weight?  Maybe.

Should it replace a sensible lifestyle plan that combines clean eating with regular exercise?  Definitely not.

If your goal is to make a lifestyle change and lose weight in the process, we’re here to help.  We have trained pharmacists and nutritionists on staff who can help you develop  a plan to eat “clean”, rid your body of toxins, and shed some pounds in the process.  We also work with experts in fitness who can create a program specifically for you to achieve optimal health.

It may not be a “magic bullet,” but it’s the best way I know of to achieve the results of great health and a vibrant life!

Be well.


Michael Lenz RPh, is a partner in Fallon Wellness Pharmacy of Saratoga.  He has over 10 years experience in custom compounding.  Michael has received extensive training in Bio-identical Hormone Replacement Therapy (BHRT) and Adrenal Fatigue.  He is an advocate for healthy eating and proper nutritional supplementation, and speaks frequently on the subjects of hormone health, nutrition and wellness.  Michael is currently enrolled in the Institute For Functional Medicine’s Certified Functional Medicine Practitioner Program.  He lives in Saratoga Springs, NY with his wife and 4 children.

source: natural standard database

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s